How do you turn an early performance into an audience that follows your musical?
Most writers think about building an audience when they’re getting ready to open a show.
But by then, you’ve missed some of your best opportunities.
One of the most valuable things you can do during the development of a new musical is to start building relationships with the people who might eventually become its audience.
Not just people who will buy a ticket to a reading or cabaret. People who become interested in the work itself. Who want to know what happens next. Who remember the characters, respond to the music, and begin to feel that they’ve discovered something worth following.
Audience development doesn’t begin when your show goes into production. It begins when you give people a reason to care.
A Developmental Performance Is an Invitation
When you’re developing a new musical, a cabaret offers something a full production often cannot: the opportunity to introduce your work to an audience before everything is decided.
You don’t need elaborate scenery, costumes, or choreography. You need strong material, compelling performers, and a clear sense of what makes your musical worth experiencing.
A handful of songs can introduce an audience to your characters, the world of your show, and the emotional stakes of the story.
But there’s an important distinction between performing songs from your musical and creating an experience that makes people want to see more.
Your audience doesn’t need to understand every plot point. They do need to feel something.
They need to become curious.
And ideally, when the performance ends, they should be asking the most valuable question a writer or producer can hear:
“When can I see the whole show?”
That’s the beginning of an audience relationship.
Don’t Just Present Your Musical. Give People a Reason to Follow It.
One of the mistakes I see in new musical development is treating each reading, workshop, or cabaret as a separate event.
The creative team works hard to prepare the presentation, invites friends and colleagues, performs the material, and then moves on to the next developmental step.
But what happens to the people who attended?
Do they hear about the next reading? Do they receive news when the musical is selected for a festival? Are they invited to follow its progress?
Or does the creative team start from scratch the next time it needs an audience?
Every developmental presentation should accomplish two things.
- First, it should help the creative team learn something about the work.
- Second, it should create an opportunity to build an audience for the work’s future.
The first advances the musical. The second helps create the conditions in which that musical might eventually be produced.
And both require intentional producing.
Five Ways to Turn a Cabaret Audience into Future Supporters
1. Introduce the story, not just the songs.
People connect with characters, conflict, and emotion. Give your audience enough context to understand what they’re listening to and why it matters.
You’re not trying to explain the entire book of the musical. You’re helping them enter its world.
2. Make your audience curious about what happens next.
Choose material that reveals something compelling without resolving everything. A cabaret should satisfy an audience emotionally while leaving them wanting to experience the complete musical.
3. Capture the connection while it’s happening.
Give people a simple way to follow your show’s development: an email list, a website, or a social media account dedicated to the project.
Invite them to stay connected. Don’t assume they’ll remember to look for you six months later.
4. Follow up after the performance.
Thank the people who attended. Share a photograph, a development milestone, or an update about the next step.
Let them know that their presence mattered.
And when you have another presentation, invite them back.
5. Think beyond the people already in your circle.
Friends and family are wonderful supporters, but a future production needs an audience beyond the creative team’s personal contacts.
Who is this musical for? Where do those people gather? Which communities, organizations, and cultural interests might connect with its subject matter?
Start reaching those people now.
The audience you build during development can become your most valuable source of early advocates when the show is ready to move forward.
Discover Three New Musicals on November 24
This philosophy is one of the reasons we created the CreateTheater Cabaret Festival.
On November 23 and 24, six new musicals will have the opportunity to introduce their work to New York audiences at the Laurie Beechman Theatre.
Last week, we introduced our November 23 musicals: Alexsei’s Quest, Bikers in Camelot, and Rewind.
This week, I’d like to introduce the three musicals taking the stage on Tuesday, November 24.
SECRETS: LOVE, LOYALTY & CRIME
Book, Music & Lyrics by Mark Sherry
Against a backdrop of the WWI, economic turmoil and rising political extremism, Rose, one of Australia’s first female lawyers, agrees to defend her brother-in-law Joe against charges of arson and treason. She despises his politics, but family loyalty demands that she stand beside him—even as she begins to question his innocence.
With her sister’s happiness at stake and a prosecutor determined to seek revenge, Rose must confront the limits of her professional confidence and decide how far she’s willing to go for family.
THE CANDLE
Book, Music & Lyrics by Zach Walters
A year after losing his grandfather, college senior Josh is struggling with grief, adulthood, and the relationships he hasn’t quite figured out.
When lighting a memorial candle unexpectedly brings his grandfather Charlie back for one extraordinary evening, the two embark on a nighttime journey through Boston—reconnecting across generations and discovering what it means to move forward without leaving love behind.
JULIE D’
Book, Music & Lyrics by Rich Buley-Neumar and Michael McCarthy
Before there were rock stars, there was Julie d’Aubigny.
A sword-wielding, convention-defying opera singer in the France of Louis XIV, Julie lived a life too extraordinary to be contained by the expectations of her time.
With a voice to match her fearless personality, she challenged convention, embraced adventure, and became the stuff of legend.
Three very different musicals. Three different worlds. Three opportunities for audiences to discover something new.
And for these creative teams, the performance is more than a chance to share songs. It’s an opportunity to find the people who may want to follow their musicals into the future.
Your Ticket Helps Create the Next Opportunity
There’s another reason this Festival matters.
100% of ticket sales from the CreateTheater Cabaret Festival will support performance space for our spring New Works Reading Series.
That means when you purchase a ticket, you’re doing more than attending an evening of new musical theater.
You’re helping CreateTheater provide the space where additional new plays and musicals can take their next developmental steps.
One audience helps create opportunities for the next group of theatermakers.
That’s how an artistic community grows.
Build the Relationship Before You Need the Audience
If you’re developing a new musical, think about your next presentation differently.
Yes, use it to test the material. Listen carefully to the audience. Notice where they’re engaged, where they’re confused, and what they respond to emotionally.
But don’t stop there.
Ask yourself what you’re doing to make sure those people can remain part of your musical’s journey.
Because the audience you build today may become the people who fill the theater tomorrow.
And when someone tells you they can’t wait to see the entire show, make sure you have a way to tell them when that day arrives.
Development should lead somewhere. Bring your audience along for the journey.
Join Us at the CreateTheater Cabaret Festival
November 23–24, 2026
The Laurie Beechman Theatre | New York City
Monday, November 23: Alexsei’s Quest, Bikers in Camelot, and Rewind
Tuesday, November 24: SECRETS: LOVE, LOYALTY & CRIME, The Candle, and Julie D
Discover six new musicals, meet the creative voices behind them, and help support the next generation of new work.
Get Your Tickets to the CreateTheater Cabaret Festival
Two evenings. Six new musicals. The chance to discover something wonderful before the rest of the world does.